The U.S. faces an enormous challenge in negotiations with Iran

Iran's Peace Demands: A Long Road Ahead

President Donald J. Trump announced that negotiations to end the war with Iran would be based on a 10-point proposal he described as "workable." Within hours, Iranian state media outlet IRNA released Tehran's own list of demands — and Trump erupted on Truth Social, calling the list "fake," a "hoax," and "made up" by "evil losers." It quickly became clear the two sides had very different proposals in mind.

[Update: A two-week ceasefire brokered by Pakistan took effect April 8, hours before Trump's deadline. Talks are now scheduled in Islamabad on April 10.]

Whether that ceasefire holds will depend on bridging enormous gaps. A look at Iran's demands shows just how unlikely a quick resolution remains.

Control of the Strait of Hormuz tops Iran's list. Tehran is already in de facto control of the Strait, the route for roughly 20 percent of the world's crude oil. In recent weeks Iran has charged ships approximately $1 per barrel in transit fees — a tacit assertion of sovereignty.

U.S. military withdrawal from the region is the second major hurdle. The U.S. maintains roughly 19–20 bases and 40,000–50,000 troops across Qatar, Bahrain, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Jordan and the UAE, with Central Command headquartered in Qatar. A full withdrawal is essentially unthinkable under current U.S. policy.

The right to nuclear enrichment is perhaps the most intractable issue. Both U.S. military strikes on Iran — in mid-2025 and on February 28 — were justified by Washington's insistence that Iran must never develop a nuclear weapon. Trump would have to abandon that rationale entirely.

Lifting all sanctions is Iran's fourth core demand. Under sanctions in place since the 1979 Revolution, Iran's oil exports have fallen to roughly 3.2 million barrels per day from a peak above 6.6 million. Removing those restrictions would allow Iran to rapidly ramp up production and reclaim a top-five spot among global exporters.

Both sides will have to make painful concessions for the ceasefire to hold — let alone for a lasting peace agreement to emerge.

 

Hilliard MacBeth

 

The opinions expressed in this report are the opinions of the author and readers should not assume they reflect the opinions or recommendations of Richardson Wealth Limited or its affiliates. Richardson Wealth Limited is a subsidiary of iA Financial Corporation Inc. and is not affiliated with James Richardson & Sons, Limited. Richardson Wealth is a trade-mark of James Richardson & Sons, Limited and Richardson Wealth Limited is a licensed user of the mark. Richardson Wealth Limited, Member Canadian Investor Protection Fund.